BA Situation Guide

What to do when you are stuck. Real questions, practical answers, relevant concepts — one place.

These are the situations every BA faces. Each answer tells you what to do right now, not just what the theory says.

Situation library

11 situations across 4 categories

📋

Requirements

📋Requirements

My stakeholder keeps changing the requirements every week. What do I do?

Changing requirements are a signal, not a problem. They usually mean the stakeholder did not have enough clarity upfront, or the business environment changed. Your job is to turn that churn into a structured process.

📋Requirements

My stakeholder says 'I will know what I want when I see it.' How do I get a real requirement?

This is one of the most common situations a BA faces. The stakeholder is not being difficult — they genuinely cannot articulate needs in the abstract. The solution is to give them something concrete to react to.

📋Requirements

A developer says my requirement is too vague to build. What do I fix?

A vague requirement almost always lacks one of three things: a defined actor, a defined trigger, or a defined measurable outcome. Check your requirement against all three before going back to the developer.

📋Requirements

I have 30 requirements and no idea which to do first. How do I prioritise?

Never prioritise alone. Prioritisation without stakeholder input is just a BA's guess — it has no authority. Your job is to facilitate the decision, not make it unilaterally.

🤝

Stakeholders

🤝Stakeholders

Two stakeholders want opposite things. Who do I listen to?

This is not a BA problem to solve — it is a governance problem. Your role is to surface the conflict clearly and escalate it to the right decision-maker, not to pick a side.

🤝Stakeholders

I cannot get time in the diary with the key stakeholder. How do I move forward?

Blocked access to a key stakeholder is a project risk, not a personal problem. Escalate it as a risk — do not just keep sending meeting invites that get ignored.

🔄

Agile & Ceremonies

🔄Agile & Ceremonies

The team completed a story but it does not match what the business expected. What went wrong?

This is almost always a Definition of Done or Acceptance Criteria failure. The story was built against the developer's interpretation rather than a testable, agreed specification.

🔄Agile & Ceremonies

My team is using Kanban but work keeps piling up and nothing gets finished. What is wrong?

A Kanban board where work piles up usually has one of two problems: no work-in-progress limits, or items are too large to move across the board in a reasonable time.

📄

Documentation

📄Documentation

I do not know whether to write a BRD or user stories. Which one do I use?

The format follows the methodology. In Waterfall or Hybrid projects with formal sign-off gates, write a BRD. In Agile projects, write User Stories. In many real enterprises, you write both.